I don’t trust Damon Lindelhoff—the showrunner of HBO’s Watchmen. He’s a damn compelling writer, but he is one that often conflates philosophical inquiry with good storytelling, which can result in pretentiously puzzling television; of which I’m very familiar. That said, I can’t stop watchingWatchmen (no pun intended) and that may be because, as many on Twitter have professed, Watchmen is the“Blackest” show on television.

Ahistoricism is dangerous and I am well aware that creating any Black character untouched by the legacy of The Atlantic Slave Trade—anywhere along the Diaspora—is an act of violence via erasure. During an interview with Reelblack, a Black film archival company out of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Dr. Tufuku Zuberi said about ahistorical artistry, “[W]e don’t simply communicate with people, simply by our own imagination. Our imagination is in the shadow of the past.”

 

Why There Can Be No Rebuilding The American Middle Class Without Focus On The Latino Community

 

Zuberi’s words in mind, I realize the question is framed incorrectly. It is less a question of whether trauma shouldexist but how it exists. The question of how Lindelhoff uses violence, especially in relationship to Black bodies, I believe exists in one of the shows most daring reveals: The origin of Hooded Justice.

Hooded Justice is known as the first superhero of Alan Moore’s The Watchmen universe. I won’t get too deep into the lore, as I feel it is an important work of literature well worth the time of discovery, but I will say that Hooded Justice’s vigilantism is the spark that lights the flame of every iconic moment of this beloved work.

Lindelhoff, and co-writer, Cord Jefferson took this character and offered him an origin story that made him a Black man who is haunted by the memories of having witnessed his parents be murdered by the Ku Klux Klan in the 1921 Tulsa Massacre. The man, William Reeves, becomes a police officer and discovers corruption among fellow white officers. They attempt to lynch him for attempting to discover a conspiracy, but he survives and proceeds to use the rope and hood from his assault to take on the corrupt officers—who happen to be members of the Ku Klux Klan.

Source: Why must Black heroism in fiction be continuously made of our historical injury?